csrins

Student. Teacher. Softsmith.

Archive for the 'The Phantom' Category


Comic-book Quicktake: Checkmate Pt 4 of 5

Posted by csrins on June 28, 2008

The Phantom #24

Issue 24 of American publisher Moonstone’s run of The Phantom is a definite winner!

The continuity tie-ins may appear disjointed to new readers, and the story may seem frantic in pace at places.

However, setting up the Guardian of the Eastern Dark is orchestrated quite well, and writer Mike Bullock appears to be reining in the divergent plot-threads in preparation for the “double-sized” finale in issue 25.

Silvestre Szilagyi’s artwork does not disappoint, and it’s a refreshing change to see a hero who’s human, and not a contorted lump of muscle!

Rick Leonardi and Terry Austin should realize that the Phantom is not “just another hyper-muscled superhero”. But for this jarring bit, the cover is pretty good!


The artwork featured in this post is copyright King Features Syndicate, Inc. and published by Moonstone, and is merely presented for informational purposes.

Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial-No Derivative Works 3.0 Unported License.

Posted in Comics, Moonstone, Opinion, Pop Culture, Quick Takes, Reviews, The Phantom | No Comments »

Comic-book Review: Walker’s Line Pt 1 of 2

Posted by csrins on March 18, 2007

Moonstone Phantom #14American publisher Moonstone’s 14th offering in its regular comic-book series of new adventures of the Phantom has the Ghost Who Talks educating one of his offspring.

This issue is written by Mike Bullock, who assumed rein of the series from ish 12 (Tiger’s Blood Pt 1 of 2). It’s illustrated by Carlos Magno (Tiger’s Blood Pt 2 of 2), and colored by Bob Pedroza. The cover art is serviced by Joe Prado, Carlos Magno, Rod Reis. Lettering is handled by Troy Peteri.

The story is a tip of the hat to the classic daily tale Jungle City (18 Sep 1978 to 16 Dec 1978). Jungle City had the Phantom searching for muggers who took Dave Palmer’s badge. It is a grim and gritty story, and illustrates the Phantom’s code excellently.

But, we digress.

Walker’s Line is about the Phantom’s concept of justice, and serves as a clear differentiation between the purple-long-johns clad masked fighter and Frank Castle (the other guy in comics who sports the skull). The Phantom is not Judge Dreddesque in character, and is merely an instrument and not the ends of justice.

When young Kit Walker asks his father, the 21st Phantom, whether he killed “the bad guyswho killed the tigers in the previous issues in the series, he is subjected to a tale (peppered with cliffhangers no less!) of the 21st’s tryst with his oath in his formative years.

The tale thus told is set in the context of the 21st Phantom’s search for the gun-belt of his father (37th Sunday story, 7 Feb 1954 to 6 Jun 1954). Interestingly the reference to this quest utilizes Egmont’s recent rendering of the Year One arc, with the quest for the belt taking place in the 21st Phantom’s first year, and not much later.

So, back to the tale at hand. Kit Walker (the 21st Phantom) is visiting his aunt Bessie and uncle Ephraim in Clarksville. But grim news awaits young Kit. Aunt Bessie is the victim of a mugging and the necklace which bears the Phantom’s good mark has been taken.

Young Kit is shaken “to the core”. So, after a brief encounter with a senior citizen in what appears to be a busliner depot, the Phantom begins stalking Clarksville for the street gangs and mopping them up.

The street gangs are as bad as they can be Hollywood style and they look evil enough. You can look at the pictures and say, “Right. These are the bad guys.”

While the Phantom’s punching the daylights out of two thugs and questioning about the necklace, he is overheard by the rogue in question. Off heads the gangster to the hospital where Bessie is, saying “It’s time to finish what I started”. Meanwhile, the Phantom lets rage get the better of him and is smashed into unconsciousness by the thugs.

More to come, we are assured, by the To be continued… caption box.

The cover art is definitely eye-catching. But what’s up with the extra huge bulging thighs for the Phantom?! Better proportion is called for here!

The printing’s a bit too dark, and speech balloons are inverted between characters in one panel.

Carlos Magno’s art is definitely a huge departure from other styles of Phantom artists, but perhaps is suited to the grim tone of the story. The panels convey rapid action, and have a certain dynamism about them. At times the Phantom appears too much of a caricature of twisted rage though! But why do everyone’s fingers appear in bent and highly unnatural positions?

The opening argument for the story is too weak. Kit Jr should know better than to ask his father whether he killed the “bad guys” because they killed the tigers. Either he’s been badly educated or has been experimenting with Guran’s “amnesia drug” (see the daily strips for more information). Mike Bullock should/could have come up with a better springboard for the story.

The weak opening is compounded by rather jarring droppings of old jungle sayings throughout the story. They simply seem out of place in a first-person narrative. And for the most part they mostly feel gratuitous (at least in this story).

The quality of the dialog fluctuates a lot from witty to outright inane as the story progresses.

And oh, about the necklace which plays a central role - it doesn’t protect, the wearer is under the Phantom’s protection, and if any harm comes to them, or worse, if they are killed, they will certainly be avenged by the Ghost Who Walks. However, as per legend in the stories, the wearer of the mark receives protection since most thugs back off at the sign of the good mark.

But that is obviously not the case for the street gangs of Clarksville.

Walker’s Line shows that Mike Bullock and Moonstone still have miles to go before they get to cranking up the bar for the Phantom. But it’s definitely an interesting journey worth watching, seeing the portent of things to come.

Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivs 2.5 License.

The artwork featured in this post is copyright King Features Syndicate, Inc. and published by Moonstone, and is merely presented for informational purposes.

Posted in Comics, Moonstone, Opinion, Reviews, The Phantom | No Comments »

Comic-book Review: Five Days of the Dragon

Posted by csrins on February 10, 2007

Moonstone Annual #1This is a follow-up on my recent discussion of Moonstone Books’ The Phantom Annual #1.

My vote for the Annual is Average, but it is arguably the best effort by Moonstone so far. What I disliked most was Mike Bullock’s part, which read like a dumb script and Juan Ferreyra’s totally crappy depiction of Guran! I really hate to think about the editorial process they have at Moonstone, but if the turbaned midget in the evening suit is Guran, then any idiot in purple long-johns can be marketed as the Phantom.

Ron Marz’s script has glaring inconsistencies. Is that a wolf in the skull cave in the panel on the 2nd page? And what’s the totally inane deal calling the 3rd Phantom’s horse Hero? Lazy scripting.

Tony Bedard and Allan Goldman raise the storyline up many notches with their dark and foreboding 2nd part. It’s perhaps one of the most impressive storylines crafted to date.

Graham Nolan is clearly in his element in Part 3, and for a change, Chuck Dixon gets the Phantom right (remember the pistol-whippin’ superhero in Slave Train? ugh) I don’t mind the fact that we don’t really see the Phantom until the final 4 pages of this part (discounting pages 3 and 6).

Part 4 by Rafael Nieves is also serviceable. But messrs. Akins and Wolak disappoint sorely. Though the art seems a tribute to strips in Milton Caniff’s heydays, it’s just not good enough.

Now, the conclusion in the fifth part. After such a build-up over the preceding 4 parts, this falls short of the task. The artwork is different indeed with the painted feel to it, but it’s visually pretty static. The Ghost Who Edits caption subtext in a panel is totally out of context and comes across as a rather lame attempt to ramp up the number of words on the page.

But what really takes the cake is the major-domo standing stiffly next to the Ghost who wears bleeding bandages and mouths the not-so-less-mouthful: Your mission is complete, Phantom. You almost expect him to say next: Would you like anything else with your order?

The major failing of the story is the basic premise. Wouldn’t it have been simpler for the 3rd Phantom to destroy the first piece of the dragon when he acquired it? What’s the whole deal with generations working to get the pieces and then having the 21st hand it over, gift-wrapped, no less? And the Sing(h) Brotherhood stories are overdone, in Moonstone lore and Egmont lore.

The layout of the cover (by Blevins and Austin) is good, but what’s the deal with the Phantom looking like some super-Skrull (as in Fantastic Four) wannabe? The Phantom’s face looks barely anthropoid in the cover illustration.

So yes, the journey was more exciting than the destination.
Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivs 2.5 License.

The artwork featured in this post is copyright King Features Syndicate, Inc. and published by Moonstone, and is merely presented for informational purposes.

Posted in Comics, Moonstone, Reviews, The Phantom | 2 Comments »

The Return of Chatu [15 May 06 to 2 September 06]

Posted by csrins on February 5, 2007

The 217th Daily Story features the return of the Python of Bangalla, Chatu.

The Ghost Who Speaks in Spooky Tones uses some psychology on the renegade Wambesi killer in this rather off-beat tale. The story once again highlights what makes the Phantom such an interesting and different character from the regular band of long underwear vigilantes strutting around in comicdom.

The Chatu yet once again seemingly bests the Ghost Who Walks, taking advantage of the Phantom’s code of not killing without reason. But this is what makes the story an interesting read. We do not have the protagonist filled with remorse or self-doubt, wallowing in self-pity, or drowning in shame and guilt. What we see in this tale is a battle of wits between an ordered and logical mind and an unpredictable maniac.

It will be interesting to see how writer Tony DePaul scripts out the next confrontation between the Phantom and the Python.

Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivs 2.5 License.

The daily strip art of 7 July 2006 featured in this post is copyright King Features Syndicate, and is merely presented for informational purposes.

Posted in Comics, The Phantom | 2 Comments »

Moonstone Books’ The Phantom Annual #1

Posted by csrins on February 3, 2007

The Annual builds up fine, but then is a complete let down.

Imagine this: you’re watching a well-orchestrated bout… and all it takes is one badly crafted sucker punch to spoil the end.

Or better still: you have a wonderful meal, and in the last morsels off the plate… you uncover… a dead roach!

That’s exactly the case here.

Mike Bullock’s segment has the weakest script but he also had the most unenviable uphill task — the conclusion of the tale.

Still it might be considered a nitpick (among a few others in the book).

But, Juan Ferreyra and Mike Bullock are unpardonably guilty of a most horrible travesty: The turbaned major-domo poseur (thanks a heap, Paramount!) is no Guran.

So, Mike and Ron: Hang your heads in shame!

Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivs 2.5 License.

Posted in Comics, Moonstone, Opinion, Reviews, The Phantom | 2 Comments »

Rogues Gallery: Chatu

Posted by csrins on May 24, 2006

ChatuChatu, a.k.a The Python is a renegade Wambesi killer who made his first newspaper story appearance in the 2003 Sunday story 'Terror in Mawitaan'. Almost an equal to the current Phantom in physical prowess, Chatu nearly bests the Phantom during their encounter. As cunning as a fox in his plot for Bangallan supremacy, Chatu exploits the Phantom's only apparent weakness: guilelessness. Unlike many others, Chatu maintains a strong belief that the Phantom is but a mere mortal. The Python displays a flair for widescreen grandstanding, and craves wealth, pleasure, and power (not necessarily in the same order). Ironically, Chatu's first encounter with the Phantom was as a child, when the 20th Phantom visited the Wambesi.

Chatu makes a reappearance in the current daily The Return of Chatu.

Posted in Comics, The Phantom | 2 Comments »

Jungle Trek

Posted by csrins on April 26, 2006

That’s the title of the current daily story featuring the Phantom. This is a totally different story from offerings in recent times… we see again a focus on the family side of the Phantom.

Comicdom’s first masked superhero was human long before Marvel’s legendary sensitization of long-underwear folks!

Tony DePaul’s scripting and Paul Ryan’s artwork prove that a superhero story is not just about bashing up the bad guys.

And this is where the Phantom traditionally differs from most other wide-screen carnage oriented superhero stories… we can actually take something valuable from the story!

Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivs 2.5 License.

The daily strip art of 25 April 2006 featured in this post is copyright King Features Syndicate, and is merely presented for informational purposes.

Posted in Comics, The Phantom | No Comments »

Comic-book Review: The Halloween Gang

Posted by csrins on April 24, 2006

Cover Art Publisher: Egmont Imagination (India) Ltd.
Appeared: March 2002
Price: 20 INR
PP: 31
Also appeared: Fantomen 22/1999, and Frew 1246

Text: Claes Reimerthi Artwork: Hans Lindahl
Story Rating: (3/5) The Phantom tackles crime in Modern Denkali.It's Halloween time in Denkali, where new customs and traditions are finally taking root.The Jungle Patrol's Second-in-Charge, Colonel Worobu's young nephew Paul Ariba is trick-or-treating with a group of friends when a man in a pumpkin head mask kidnaps the little boy. A while later, the boy's parents receive a ransom note demanding 250,000 pounds for the boy's release. The note is also accompanied by a replica of a severed human finger. Three other boys have also been kidnapped within the hour.

Acting swiftly, the Morristown Police Department tracks down the kidnappers' getaway vehicle, which explodes after a mechanical pumpkin-head delivers a sombre warning.

Colonel Worobu rushes to his sister's house when he learns the news. Present there are Martha and Carrion Crane, whose son has was also kidnapped along with Paul. Carrion Crane is not satisfied with the Police Department's treatment of the case and imploresColonel Worobu to do something. Promising to ask his mysterious commander for help, Worobu leaves a message for the Phantom in the safe in the windowless room in Jungle Patrol Headquarters.

Meanwhile, the Morristown Police set a trap for the kidnappers. In a meeting with the concerned parents, the Captain explains that the ransom will be delivered in a bag with a hidden transmitter, and the police will keep a sharp lookout at the drop point.

After meeting with Worobu, the Phantom surveys Central Park, where the ransom drop is to be made at midnight. Spotting two thugs, the Phantom immediately keeps watch on them. At midnight, the ransom drop is made. However, the crooks are too clever for the waiting policemen and make their getaway. But not before the Phantom hitches a ride atop their van.

Casing the kidnappers' hideout, the Phantom trips a hidden alarm and is knocked unconscious by a strong current shock. When he comes to, he finds himself bound, and relieved of his firearms. However, the Phantom frees himself with a knife hidden in his boot. The Phantom locates the children, when the gang's leader arrives. By a quirk of fate, the gang-leader manages to escape with Paul Ariba.

The scene shifts to the Crane residence, where Crane and his wife discuss the Aribas' plight. Young Paul has still not been returned. Excusing himself, Crane leaves for his electronics factory. Entering the premises, he is shocked to find a huge skull mark near the fusebox. Suddenly, an electronic pumpkin of the kind manufactured by Crane begins to talk, detailing his role in the kidnapping. The Phantom states that all the electronic pumpkin heads used by the kidnappers had come from Crane's factory, and that was what led the Phantom to him. In a frenzy, Crane tries to shoot the Phantom, but Devil is waiting and ready. However, Crane uses an instrument to stun Devil with a stupefying shock and tries to make good his escape. But the Phantom removes the fuses and the electronic gates do not open and Crane's car crashes. Leaving the unconscious Carrion Crane and rescuing Paul Ariba, the Phantom leaves the scene as the Police arrive.

Young Paul is home again, and Worobu remarks that every crook bore the skull mark on their jaw, indicating the unknown Commander's handiwork.

The story held tremendous potential at the start, but petered out in the end. The panels on Page 27 showing Crane talking with his wife are a dead giveaway of whatever suspense there was up to this point.When the Phantom confronts Crane, Crane thunders that the Phantom has tricked him into a confession. But such a thing never happens in the story. The talking pumpkin head merely states the Phantom's deductions, and Crane never admits his role until later.Additionally, the Phantom is not a vigilante like the Batman, he does not "vanish" from the scene when police arrive, as has been shown in the story. On the contrary, he stays around to make sure that no criminal escapes.Why, oh why, does anyone not unmask the Phantom when they do not know who he is? The crooks capture the Phantom, relieve him of his weapons, tie him up, and still leave the mask on?! Since they did not know the identity of the prowler, there is no reason to fear unmasking the Phantom? Doesn't say much about the storytelling department, does it?

Finally, Worobu's remark that all the crooks had been marked by the Phantom does not ring true. Are we to assume that the Phantom marked an unconscious Carrion Crane?

A good story, but it could have been developed better.

Artwork Rating: (3/5) This is not a "happening" story. There is not much action in the tale. However, the panels where the Phantom plays a cat-and-mouse game with the kidnappers are very good. The thugs are clearly fearful of a foe they cannot even see, but who is dropping them down like flies. Thus, the only reason why the artwork doesn't rate higher is because of the constraints imposed by the story.
Cover Rating: (1/5) The less said the better. A highly insipid collage of pictures taken from the first page of the book which deals with the Phantom Legend. Since I chose a policy of not giving a zero rating…
Overall Rating: (2/5) The story is passable, even good. There is nothing much to complain abou the artwork. However the entire book leaves much to be desired. The printing is outright shoddy and bad. The colors are awful, and pages 14 and 15 show scarcely any details of the artwork, thanks to the low quality of printing. All in all an unappealing package, inspite of the story or artwork.

Posted in Comics, Reviews, The Phantom | No Comments »